Office: 1700 Scherer Pkwy, St Charles, MO Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 9–2 · Sun closed (314) 730-4080

Planning a Metal Roof Replacement

Should Chimney Repairs Happen Before a Metal Roof? Midwest Planning Guide

In Missouri and Illinois, chimney condition should shape the roof-replacement plan. This guide explains when masonry work comes first, how flashing is coordinated, and what homeowners should document before installation.

Quick answer

Usually yes: complete any repair that changes the chimney’s shape, masonry, crown, or roof-side condition before installing a new metal roof so the roofing crew can design base, step, and counterflashing around a stable surface. If work is minor and won’t disturb flashing, trades may agree on a different sequence in writing.

Key takeaways

  • Repair unstable, cracked, spalling, or water-damaged chimney masonry before final metal-roof flashing is fabricated[2].
  • Have the roofer and chimney professional agree on who removes, replaces, embeds, and seals each flashing component; flashing is a water-shedding transition, not just caulk[2][3].
  • Ask for a written plan covering roof deck condition, cricket or saddle needs, underlayment, material compatibility, permits, and final inspection[1][3].
  • Do not climb onto the roof to investigate. Photograph visible conditions from the ground and have qualified professionals evaluate safety, combustion, and structural questions.

Why does sequence matter for a chimney and metal roof?

A chimney is one of the largest penetrations in a residential roof assembly. Building America guidance says the roof-to-chimney connection must join the roof’s water-control layer to the chimney’s water-control layer; typical metal elements are base flashing, step flashing, and counterflashing[2]. It is an interface that must be designed into the roof system.

Installing a new roof first can make later masonry work disruptive. Repointing, rebuilding a shoulder, correcting a crown, or changing chimney dimensions may require disturbing newly installed flashing and panels. Repairing the chimney first gives the roofing team a stable substrate and lets the final detail shed water in layers, consistent with code, manufacturer instructions, and the actual chimney geometry[1][2].

Which chimney condition should happen before the metal roof?
Observed conditionTypical planning responseWho confirms it
Loose, leaning, or structurally damaged masonryRepair or rebuild first; remeasure before final flashing[2]Chimney/masonry professional
Spalled brick, failed mortar, or damaged crownComplete moisture-related masonry work first, allowing required cure timeMasonry professional
Sound chimney with deteriorated roof flashingCoordinate removal and replacement with the roof installation[2][3]Roofer plus chimney professional
Cosmetic work away from roof intersectionMay be scheduled separately if it cannot disturb final flashingBoth trades in writing

When should masonry be repaired before roofing?

Prioritize chimney work before the roof when visible masonry is loose, stepped, badly cracked, leaning, or missing mortar; when brick or stone is spalling; or when the crown, cap, or flue enclosure allows water into the assembly. These conditions need a chimney or masonry professional’s evaluation.

Midwest weather makes moisture management especially important. Water entering porous masonry can combine with repeated freezing and thawing, so a small defect may become a larger maintenance problem over time. The practical decision is not whether Missouri or Illinois automatically requires a particular repair; it is whether the chimney is sound, dry, and ready to receive a durable flashing transition before the roof crew closes the surrounding area[2].

Which chimney repairs can be coordinated with roofing?

Not every chimney task must delay every roof task. A professional may recommend completing a limited repointing or replacing a cap while the existing roof remains temporarily protected, then having the roofer install final flashing after the masonry has cured and the dimensions are confirmed. The written scopes should identify cure times, temporary weather protection, and the handoff inspection so that neither trade assumes the other owns the risk.

The key distinction is whether the repair changes the flashing plane or the chimney’s exterior. Cosmetic cleaning that does not affect the roof intersection is different from rebuilding the back wall, raising the crown, or replacing a chimney cricket. When in doubt, have the roofer measure after masonry work, not before. This avoids fabricating a precise metal detail around a surface that is about to change[2][3].

How does chimney flashing work with metal roofs?

Flashing should direct water away from the penetration. IBHS describes counterflashing as the upper component of a two-piece assembly that protects the top edge of base flashing around penetrations such as chimneys; the base flashing is secured independently, and the upper piece is secured into or against the chimney[3]. Building America likewise describes layered base, step, and counterflashing, with a cricket or saddle where runoff meets the upslope side[2].

Metal roofing adds movement and material-compatibility considerations. IBHS notes that metals expand and contract differently from masonry, and that flashing details should accommodate movement; it also warns that dissimilar metals can accelerate galvanic corrosion[3]. The installer should therefore follow the selected roof system’s details for seams, laps, fasteners, sealants, and compatible metals instead of relying on a generic bead of sealant. Local code and the manufacturer’s instructions control the final assembly[1][3].

What is a practical Missouri and Illinois planning sequence?

Start with a ground-level conversation: record interior stains, past leak locations, visible cracks, loose materials, chimney height and width, and whether the fireplace or appliance is still used. Then arrange the appropriate professional evaluations. The mason or chimney specialist addresses masonry, crown, cap, liner, and combustion-related concerns; the roofer addresses deck, drainage, underlayment, roof geometry, and the metal system.

Next, put the handoffs in writing. Confirm whether the old flashing is removed, whether damaged deck is replaced, who supplies the cricket, how temporary exposure is protected, and who schedules permit or inspection steps with the local authority. Code language requires roof assemblies to be installed in accordance with the code and approved manufacturer instructions, and reroofing provisions can affect tear-off or recover decisions[1]. A short preconstruction meeting can prevent expensive ambiguity.

What should be in contractor proposals for chimneys and metal roofs?

A useful proposal should name the metal roof type, underlayment approach, roof areas included, chimney flashing scope, deck-repair allowance or process, ventilation work, cleanup, and exclusions. For a standing-seam system, ask how the chimney detail accommodates panel seams and movement. For stone-coated steel shingles, ask how courses, valleys, and flashing integrate with the profile.

Bishop's Metal Roofing states that it installs stone-coated steel shingles and standing-seam metal roofing and does not install asphalt shingles, tile, slate, cedar, membrane roofing, or exposed-fastener panels on homes. Ask Bishop's for the current written scope, product documentation, warranty terms, and any financing offer in writing; the manifest says actual written terms control, and this article makes no promise about price, insurance, lifespan, or outcome.

How should final inspection and handoff be handled?

After masonry and roofing are complete, request a walk-through from safe locations. Look for a continuous-looking transition, clean drainage paths, properly finished metal edges, and no obvious gaps or loose components. Ask for photographs of concealed underlayment and flashing where available, product and installation documents, permit records if applicable, and the names of the responsible trades. Do not treat a visual walk-through as proof that a chimney liner or hidden structure is safe.

Keep the records with your home documents and schedule future checks through qualified professionals, especially after severe weather or if stains, odors, loose masonry, or new interior moisture appear. A good sequence reduces rework; it cannot guarantee that a roof or chimney will never leak. Local authorities, licensed professionals, and the current roof and flashing instructions govern project-specific decisions[1][3].

This article provides general planning information, not a diagnosis, engineering opinion, chimney-safety certification, building-code determination, legal advice, financial advice, insurance advice, or instructions for climbing or working on a roof. Conditions vary by home, municipality, adopted code, roof system, chimney construction, and manufacturer instructions. Have qualified professionals inspect the property and confirm the scope, permits, safety requirements, and current written terms before work begins. Bishop's Metal Roofing business facts are separated from general evidence and do not constitute a performance guarantee.

FAQ

Should Chimney Repairs Happen Before a Metal Roof: common questions

Can a metal roof be installed before chimney repair?

Flashing is designed around actual geometry, and code requires moisture-shedding details at roof penetrations[1]. If a qualified professional confirms that the masonry is stable and the planned work will not disturb the flashing plane, the trades may coordinate a different order with temporary protection and written responsibility.

Does a chimney cricket matter with metal roofing?

It can. The 2021 IRC calls for a cricket or saddle on the ridge side of a chimney or penetration more than 30 inches wide, measured perpendicular to the slope[1]. Its purpose is to redirect runoff around the upslope side rather than letting water collect against the obstruction. Actual requirements depend on the adopted local code, chimney dimensions, roof design, and product detail. Have the roofer measure the chimney and document whether a cricket is included, excluded, or unnecessary under the applicable rules.[1][1]

Who should repair chimney flashing: a mason or roofer?

The answer depends on the component. A mason or chimney specialist may repair the masonry, crown, cap, or mortar joints; a metal-roof contractor typically designs and installs the roof-integrated flashing. IBHS describes counterflashing and base flashing as a coordinated two-piece water-control assembly[3]. The safest comparison shopping question is not which trade gets sole ownership, but who is responsible for each layer, how the handoff is inspected, and what happens if hidden deck or masonry damage is found.[3][3]

What should Missouri and Illinois homeowners ask before signing?

Ask whether the chimney repair is included or excluded; who inspects masonry and any liner concerns; whether the roof is a replacement or recover; how damaged deck is handled; what underlayment and cricket detail are proposed; which metals, fasteners, and sealants are compatible; who obtains permits; and who returns if a concealed condition changes the scope. Request current manufacturer instructions and written warranty terms. Code and approved installation instructions govern the assembly[1][3], not a generic promise that it is waterproof.[1][3][1][3]

Can Bishop's Metal Roofing evaluate my chimney?

A roofing consultation can address the roof plane, roof-side flashing, deck, and metal system, but it should not be treated as a chimney-masonry, liner, combustion, engineering, or code-official diagnosis. Ask which conditions are within the roofing scope and coordinate a qualified chimney or masonry professional when needed. Obtain the current written scope, warranty, and any financing terms directly from Bishop's before relying on them.[1][1]

References

Sources

  1. Chimneys Connected to Roof Structure — U.S. Department of Energy Building America Solution Center / PNNL
  2. 2021 International Residential Code, Chapter 9: Roof Assemblies — International Code Council
  3. Metal Flashing — Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety
  4. Metal Roof Installation Manual — Metal Construction Association
  5. The NRCA Roofing Manual — National Roofing Contractors Association
  6. Footsteps: Fort Larned’s Past (transcript) — National Park Service

Built to last. Backed by Bishop's.

Make your next roof your last.

Two metal systems, one installation standard. In a consultation we inspect the roof, explain which system fits the house, and put the scope, warranty and financing options in writing.

Schedule consultation Call now