Invest once
Roof lifetime cost calculator
Enter what an asphalt shingle roof would cost on your home. See what one metal roof costs over 50 years after insurance and energy savings.
Example: $15,000 asphalt roof, 50 years
Metal saves you about $21,915
We estimate the metal roof at about 2.3 times your asphalt price, the ratio in our $35,000 vs. $15,000 example. Savings assume a 10% insurance discount on the average Missouri premium of $1,668 a year and 10% off average cooling costs. Your written proposal and your insurance agent set the real numbers. Change any number in the full calculator
Lifetime roof cost = (price × installations) + storm-claim deductibles − insurance discount − energy savings. With Missouri defaults, three $15,000 asphalt roofs plus one $2,500 hail deductible total $47,500. One $35,000 metal roof, less an insurance discount of $8,340 and cooling savings of $1,075 over 50 years, nets $25,585: $21,915 less.
Full calculator
How much will each roof cost you over time?
| Cost item | Asphalt | Metal |
|---|---|---|
| Roof installations | $45,000$15,000 × 3 | $35,000$35,000 × 1 |
| Storm-claim deductibles | $2,5001 × $2,500 deductible | $00 × $2,500 deductible |
| Insurance discount | $0standard premium | −$8,34010% of $1,668 = $166.80/yr × 50 yr |
| Energy savings | $0baseline | −$1,07510% of $215 cooling + 0% of $606 heating = $21.50/yr × 50 yr |
| Lifetime cost | $47,500 | $25,585 |
| Difference | Metal costs less | $21,915 |
Example prices and defaults are planning numbers, not quotes. Use the installed price from your written proposal, the premium and deductible from your policy, and the discount your agent confirms.
Method
What does the calculator count?
Four lines, added up for each roof over the same number of years.
| Line | Formula | Default | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roof installations | Price × times installed | Asphalt $15,000 × 3; metal $35,000 × 1 | Planning example: asphalt bought three times in the period one metal roof covers |
| Storm-claim deductibles | Claims × deductible | Asphalt 1, metal 0, at $2,500 each | About 2.8 wind/hail claims per 100 insured homes a year nationally[6]; $2,500 is 1% of $250,000 dwelling coverage |
| Insurance discount | Premium × discount × years | 10% of $1,668 (MO) or $1,343 (IL) | 2022 NAIC average premiums[6]; discount is a planning figure because discounts vary by insurer[7] |
| Energy savings | (Cooling × % + heating × %) × years | 10% of $215 (MO) or $196 (IL) cooling; 0% of heating | EIA 2020 household spending by region[1]; ORNL field measurements[2] |
- Every figure is in today's dollars, with no inflation, financing or resale effects.
- The default horizon is 50 years, matching Bishop's stated 50-year warranty term.
- Repeated tear-offs also mean repeated disruption, disposal and scheduling, which the dollar total does not capture.
- With Illinois defaults the same example comes to $47,500 for asphalt and $27,305 for metal, a $20,195 difference.
Want the details behind the comparison? Read metal roof vs. asphalt shingles over 50 years or how to compare financing offers.
Energy evidence
Does a metal roof really cut energy bills by 5–10%?
For air-conditioning costs, yes. For a whole Missouri or Illinois energy bill, usually not. The difference is what the percentage is measured against.
The strongest field data comes from Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee, a mixed climate similar to St. Louis. Light-gray stone-coated metal shakes installed on battens, with an air channel above the roof deck, cut the heat entering the roof deck by about 45% compared with asphalt shingles. Together, the reflective pigments and that air channel cut the summer heat flowing through the attic floor into the living space by 70%. The venting also eliminated the winter heating penalty a reflective roof can otherwise cause[2]. Later ORNL tests on metal roofs with a vented air space measured even larger cuts in peak daytime heat gain through the ceiling[3].
Federal sources agree on the direction but frame the size carefully. EPA reports that reflective cool roofs can lower peak cooling demand in air-conditioned homes by 11–27%[4]. ENERGY STAR notes that cool roofs save the most in hot, sunny climates and on buildings with little roof insulation[5].
Missouri and Illinois homes are heating-dominated. In 2020, Midwest households spent an average of $1,892 a year on home energy: $644 on space heating and $202 on air conditioning[1]. Roofs account for roughly 12–14% of a home's heating and cooling loads, according to research cited by the ORNL team[3]. That is about $102–$118 of the $846 a Midwest home spends on heating and cooling. Even a roof that removed all of it would save only about 5–6% of the total bill.
| Measured against | Annual base | 5–10% would be | Supported by the research? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Air-conditioning cost | $202 | $10.10–$20.20 a year | Yes, for a vented, reflective metal roof |
| Heating and cooling combined | $846 | $42.30–$84.60 a year | Possible at the low end, mostly in poorly insulated attics |
| Whole energy bill | $1,892 | $94.60–$189.20 a year | Not for typical homes; it exceeds the roof's entire share of the load |
That is why the calculator defaults to 10% of cooling costs and 0% of heating costs. Raise the cooling figure if your attic is poorly insulated or your ductwork runs through it, if you choose a lighter or cool-pigment color, or if the system is installed over battens with an air gap. Leave heating at zero unless an energy audit tells you otherwise.
Insurance
Will a metal roof lower my insurance costs in Missouri or Illinois?
There are two separate savings: a possible premium discount every year, and the deductibles you avoid when hail doesn't damage the roof.
Premium discounts. State Farm lists both Missouri and Illinois among the states where qualifying impact-resistant roofing may earn a homeowners premium discount. It requires a roofing certification form and asks homeowners to check with an agent before installing a new roof[7]. State Farm does not publish the percentage, and discounts vary by insurer, so the calculator uses 10% as a planning figure. The 2022 average homeowners premium was $1,668 in Missouri and $1,343 in Illinois, the latest NAIC figures[6]. A 10% discount on those premiums is worth $166.80 and $134.30 a year.
Deductibles you don't pay. In ISO claim data compiled by the Insurance Information Institute, about one in 35 insured homes has a wind or hail claim each year: 2.8 claims per 100 homes, averaging $14,747 per claim[6]. Over 50 years that rate works out to about 1.4 claims per home, and hail risk here is above the national average. State Farm's 2025 hail claim payments ranked Missouri second and Illinois third in the nation, behind only Texas[9]. Each claim costs your deductible first. State Farm now requires a minimum 1% wind/hail deductible in Illinois, so a policy with $250,000 of dwelling coverage pays at least $2,500 per claim[8]. Missouri's insurance department reminds homeowners that deductibles can change at renewal and can differ by type of loss[10].
- Compare like with like: Class 4 impact-rated asphalt shingles may earn a discount too. If you are comparing metal against impact-rated shingles, set the discount to zero.
- Ask about cosmetic damage: ask your agent whether your policy treats dents that don't cause leaks on a metal roof differently from functional damage.
- Keep the paperwork: save the product's impact rating and the installation certificate. The insurer needs them to apply a discount.
Break-even
How many asphalt roofs does it take for metal to cost less?
On installation prices alone, against a $35,000 metal roof, the answer depends on what asphalt costs on your house.
| Asphalt price per install | 1 install | 2 installs | 3 installs |
|---|---|---|---|
| $12,000 | $12,000 (−$23,000) | $24,000 (−$11,000) | $36,000 (+$1,000) |
| $15,000 | $15,000 (−$20,000) | $30,000 (−$5,000) | $45,000 (+$10,000) |
| $18,000 | $18,000 (−$17,000) | $36,000 (+$1,000) | $54,000 (+$19,000) |
| $22,000 | $22,000 (−$13,000) | $44,000 (+$9,000) | $66,000 (+$31,000) |
- At $12,000 per asphalt installation, metal becomes the lower installation cost once you would otherwise buy asphalt 3 times.
- At $15,000 per asphalt installation, metal becomes the lower installation cost once you would otherwise buy asphalt 3 times.
- At $18,000 per asphalt installation, metal becomes the lower installation cost once you would otherwise buy asphalt 2 times.
- At $22,000 per asphalt installation, metal becomes the lower installation cost once you would otherwise buy asphalt 2 times.
The insurance and energy lines shift the break-even point toward metal. With Missouri defaults they add $11,915 to metal's side over 50 years, about $238 a year. If you expect to sell before the first asphalt roof wears out, the first invoice matters more than the lifetime total, and resale value becomes the deciding question.
Local factors
What changes the math in Missouri and Illinois?
The replacement count and the claim count move the most, and storms move both. In NOAA's Storm Events records for 2016–2025, 89% of the 938 Missouri communities we serve and 84% of the 1,294 Illinois communities had at least one report of hail 1.75 inches or larger within 10 miles. A hail-driven replacement before an asphalt roof's normal end of life adds an installation or a claim to the asphalt column.
- Hail exposure: check your community page for its hail count and largest stone on record, then decide whether one claim and three asphalt installations are optimistic or conservative.
- Insurance: enter your own premium, deductible and the discount your agent quotes.
- How long you'll stay: shorten the horizon if you plan to move, and compare only the installations you would actually pay for.
- Roof complexity: steep pitches, dormers and valleys raise the price of both roofs. Use quotes for the same roof, not national averages.
Find your community through the Missouri or Illinois service area pages.
FAQ
Lifetime cost questions
How is lifetime roof cost calculated?
Add up what each roof costs you over the years you own the home: the installed price times the number of installations, plus the deductible for every storm claim, minus any insurance discount and energy savings the roof earns each year. The calculator does this for asphalt and metal side by side. On roof prices alone, the default example is $10,000 in metal's favor; the insurance and energy lines raise that to $21,915 with Missouri defaults.
Does a metal roof lower homeowners insurance in Missouri and Illinois?
It can. State Farm lists both Missouri and Illinois among the states where qualifying impact-resistant roofing may earn a premium discount, after you submit its roofing certification form. Insurers do not publish one standard percentage, so the calculator uses 10% as a planning figure. Replace it with the number your agent quotes, and ask before the roof is installed. Class 4 impact-rated asphalt shingles may qualify for a discount too.
Is it true a metal roof saves 5–10% on energy?
For air-conditioning costs, the research supports it. For a whole Missouri or Illinois energy bill, it usually does not. Oak Ridge National Laboratory measured 70% less summer heat through the ceiling under a vented, reflective stone-coated metal roof than under asphalt shingles. But roofs drive only about 12–14% of a home's heating and cooling loads, and Midwest homes spend about $644 a year on heating versus $202 on air conditioning. The calculator defaults to 10% of cooling costs and 0% of heating costs.
How are the deductible savings calculated?
Each storm claim costs you your wind/hail deductible before insurance pays. The default assumes one claim with asphalt over 50 years and none with metal, at $2,500 per claim. Nationally, about 2.8 of every 100 insured homes file a wind or hail claim each year, or about 1.4 claims over 50 years; the default rounds down. If insurance paid for one of your asphalt replacements, lower the asphalt installation count by one and keep the claim.
Does the calculator include inflation or financing?
No. Every figure is in today's dollars so the comparison stays simple. Roof prices, insurance premiums and energy prices have generally risen over time. The average U.S. homeowners premium rose every year from 2013 to 2022 in NAIC data, which would enlarge both the asphalt replacement costs and the yearly savings.
Where do I get real numbers for my house?
Roof prices come from a written proposal; Bishop's prices the specific roof after an inspection. Your premium and wind/hail deductible are on your policy's declarations page, and your agent can quote the impact-rated roof discount. Your utility bills show your summer cooling and winter heating costs.
References
Sources
- Residential Energy Consumption Survey 2020, Table CE3.8: Annual household site end-use expenditures in the Midwest — U.S. Energy Information Administration
- Miller, Wilson and Karagiozis (2006), The Impact of Above-Sheathing Ventilation on the Thermal and Moisture Performance of Steep-Slope Residential Roofs and Attics — Oak Ridge National Laboratory (via Texas A&M OAKTrust)
- Biswas, Miller, Kriner and Manlove (2013), A Study of the Energy-Saving Potential of Metal Roofs Incorporating Dynamic Insulation Systems — Oak Ridge National Laboratory / ASHRAE
- Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands — U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- Cool Roofs — ENERGY STAR
- Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance (ISO/Verisk claim data; NAIC average premiums by state) — Insurance Information Institute
- Homeowners insurance discounts: roofing discounts — State Farm
- Understanding the Issues in Illinois (wind/hail deductible) — State Farm Newsroom
- State Farm Paid Over $5.6 Billion in Hail Claims in 2025 — State Farm Newsroom
- Storm insurance guidance for Missourians — Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance
Real prices
Get a written price for your roof
Schedule a consultation and we'll price the system that fits your house, in writing.