Cost & Value
Should you remove your own old shingles before a metal roof?
Usually, do not remove your own shingles before a metal reroof. Roof demolition adds fall exposure, falling debris, hidden deck defects, hazardous-material and disposal issues, and installers require a written scope that confirms inspection, cleanup, and responsibility.
What factors decide whether you should remove old shingles?
- Fall and demolition exposure
- OSHA identifies re-roofing as demolition at height, with risks from uneven sheathing, wind, slick surfaces, loose materials, and falling debris. Familiarity does not replace a safe system.[1]
- Deck condition and scope
- Tear-off can reveal rot, soft spots, openings, or structural deterioration that changes work and responsibility. Exact metal-system instructions govern review of the supporting assembly.[1][6]
- Hazardous materials
- Asbestos cannot be confirmed from a photograph. Missouri guidance calls for inspection and laboratory analysis where applicable; Illinois EPA identifies regulated renovation and disposal requirements.[2][3]
- Waste logistics
- Shingles and mixed roofing debris may be accepted differently by a landfill, transfer station, or recovery facility. Missouri and Illinois guidance emphasize lawful disposal and calling ahead.[4][5]
- Written coordination
- The proposal should state whether owner demolition is included, excluded, inspected afterward, and accepted for scheduling, cleanup, warranty, and damage responsibility. This page does not state Bishop's policy.
| Condition | Risk or coordination issue | Safer next step |
|---|---|---|
| Roof work at height | Falls, slick surfaces, loose materials, and debris are unpredictable during demolition.[1] | Have the contractor define and control demolition; do not assume a ladder makes access safe. |
| Unknown deck | Tear-off may reveal rot, soft spots, openings, or structural deterioration.[1][6] | Get a written deck-inspection and concealed-condition process. |
| Suspect hazardous material | A photo cannot confirm asbestos; state requirements may involve inspection, sampling, notification, and special disposal.[2][3] | Stop and consult the authority and qualified professionals. |
| No disposal route | Roofing waste is C&D debris, not ordinary household trash; facilities may require permitted handling or advance acceptance.[4][5] | Call the receiving facility before scheduling tear-off. |
| Arrangement | What must be documented | Decision signal |
|---|---|---|
| Installer-managed | Demolition, deck review, debris, cleanup, and changes | Usually clearer responsibility when hidden conditions matter.[1][4] |
| Homeowner-managed | Written acceptance, handoff condition, inspection, debris, and responsibility | Proceed only if the installer expressly agrees in writing; no assumed Bishop's acceptance. |
| Shared or staged | Boundary, weather protection, schedule, damage, and unsuitable conditions | Avoid ambiguity where delays or rain exposure could compound.[2][6] |
What should you confirm in writing before a homeowner tear-off?
No Bishop's policy, price, or acceptance decision was inferred.[1][2][3][4][5][6]
When metal makes sense
- The deck, slope, penetrations, flashing, and assembly can be reviewed before system selection.[6]
- The owner wants one coordinated scope for tear-off, inspection, disposal, weather protection, and installation.[1][4]
- The decision rests on documented system fit, not an assumed DIY saving or service-life promise.
When it is not recommended
- Fall, weather, or unstable-deck risks cannot be responsibly controlled.[1]
- Suspect asbestos or another hazardous material has not been evaluated.[2][3]
- Lawful disposal, transport, packaging, and facility acceptance are unconfirmed.[4][5]
- The installer cannot document handoff, inspection, schedule, warranty, or concealed-condition responsibility.[6]
Run your own numbers in the roof lifetime cost calculator.
General information, not roof-access instructions, asbestos identification, legal or code advice, an estimate, or Bishop's acceptance. Confirm safety, disposal, contract, and permitting with qualified professionals and local authorities.