Office: 1700 Scherer Pkwy, St Charles, MO Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 9–2 · Sun closed (314) 730-4080

Cost & Value

Should you remove your own old shingles before a metal roof?

Quick answer

Usually, do not remove your own shingles before a metal reroof. Roof demolition adds fall exposure, falling debris, hidden deck defects, hazardous-material and disposal issues, and installers require a written scope that confirms inspection, cleanup, and responsibility.

What factors decide whether you should remove old shingles?

Fall and demolition exposure
OSHA identifies re-roofing as demolition at height, with risks from uneven sheathing, wind, slick surfaces, loose materials, and falling debris. Familiarity does not replace a safe system.[1]
Deck condition and scope
Tear-off can reveal rot, soft spots, openings, or structural deterioration that changes work and responsibility. Exact metal-system instructions govern review of the supporting assembly.[1][6]
Hazardous materials
Asbestos cannot be confirmed from a photograph. Missouri guidance calls for inspection and laboratory analysis where applicable; Illinois EPA identifies regulated renovation and disposal requirements.[2][3]
Waste logistics
Shingles and mixed roofing debris may be accepted differently by a landfill, transfer station, or recovery facility. Missouri and Illinois guidance emphasize lawful disposal and calling ahead.[4][5]
Written coordination
The proposal should state whether owner demolition is included, excluded, inspected afterward, and accepted for scheduling, cleanup, warranty, and damage responsibility. This page does not state Bishop's policy.
Pre-tear-off decision screen
ConditionRisk or coordination issueSafer next step
Roof work at heightFalls, slick surfaces, loose materials, and debris are unpredictable during demolition.[1]Have the contractor define and control demolition; do not assume a ladder makes access safe.
Unknown deckTear-off may reveal rot, soft spots, openings, or structural deterioration.[1][6]Get a written deck-inspection and concealed-condition process.
Suspect hazardous materialA photo cannot confirm asbestos; state requirements may involve inspection, sampling, notification, and special disposal.[2][3]Stop and consult the authority and qualified professionals.
No disposal routeRoofing waste is C&D debris, not ordinary household trash; facilities may require permitted handling or advance acceptance.[4][5]Call the receiving facility before scheduling tear-off.
Who controls the tear-off interface?
ArrangementWhat must be documentedDecision signal
Installer-managedDemolition, deck review, debris, cleanup, and changesUsually clearer responsibility when hidden conditions matter.[1][4]
Homeowner-managedWritten acceptance, handoff condition, inspection, debris, and responsibilityProceed only if the installer expressly agrees in writing; no assumed Bishop's acceptance.
Shared or stagedBoundary, weather protection, schedule, damage, and unsuitable conditionsAvoid ambiguity where delays or rain exposure could compound.[2][6]

What should you confirm in writing before a homeowner tear-off?

No Bishop's policy, price, or acceptance decision was inferred.[1][2][3][4][5][6]

When metal makes sense

  • The deck, slope, penetrations, flashing, and assembly can be reviewed before system selection.[6]
  • The owner wants one coordinated scope for tear-off, inspection, disposal, weather protection, and installation.[1][4]
  • The decision rests on documented system fit, not an assumed DIY saving or service-life promise.

When it is not recommended

  • Fall, weather, or unstable-deck risks cannot be responsibly controlled.[1]
  • Suspect asbestos or another hazardous material has not been evaluated.[2][3]
  • Lawful disposal, transport, packaging, and facility acceptance are unconfirmed.[4][5]
  • The installer cannot document handoff, inspection, schedule, warranty, or concealed-condition responsibility.[6]

Run your own numbers in the roof lifetime cost calculator.

General information, not roof-access instructions, asbestos identification, legal or code advice, an estimate, or Bishop's acceptance. Confirm safety, disposal, contract, and permitting with qualified professionals and local authorities.

FAQ

Common questions about this topic

Can I save money by removing the shingles myself?

Falls, disposal, weather protection, deck discoveries, and unclear responsibility can outweigh an apparent saving. Compare written scopes only; any rendered illustration is not a quote or forecast.[1][4][5]

Can I remove shingles from the ground or with a ladder?

Do not use this page as roof-access or tear-off instructions. OSHA identifies fall protection, structural review, and training as parts of roofing work; an ordinary ladder is not a complete safety plan. A qualified contractor should define controls.[1]

Can a photo tell me whether old roofing contains asbestos?

No. A photograph cannot confirm asbestos. Missouri guidance calls for certified inspection and laboratory analysis in regulated situations; Illinois EPA identifies renovation and disposal requirements. Do not disturb suspect material based on a visual guess.[2][3]

Where can old shingles be disposed of?

It depends on material, jurisdiction, and facility. Missouri directs C&D waste to permitted facilities; Illinois identifies shingles as general C&D debris and recommends confirming a permitted recovery facility or hauler. Call ahead about acceptance.[4][5]

Will the installer inspect the deck after I tear off?

Only the written scope can answer that. Ask who examines exposed sheathing, documents deterioration, protects the open roof, authorizes repairs, and decides whether installation proceeds. Do not assume inspection is included.[6]

Does Bishop's accept homeowner-prepared tear-off?

Ask for written terms covering handoff, deck inspection, debris, schedule, damage responsibility, and warranty.

References

Sources

  1. Reducing Falls During Residential Construction: Re-Roofing — Occupational Safety and Health Administration
  2. Asbestos Requirements for Demolition and Renovation Projects — Missouri Department of Natural Resources
  3. Asbestos — Illinois Environmental Protection Agency
  4. Managing Construction and Demolition Waste (PUB2045) — Missouri Department of Natural Resources
  5. Construction and Demolition Debris — Kane County, Illinois
  6. MCA Roofing Installation Manual — Metal Construction Association / McElroy Metal

Built to last. Backed by Bishop's.

Make your next roof your last.

Two metal systems, one installation standard. In a consultation we inspect the roof, explain which system fits the house, and put the scope, warranty and financing options in writing.

Schedule consultation Call now