Metal Roofing Comparisons
Metal Roof vs. Cedar Shakes
Metal roofing and cedar shakes can both suit steep-slope homes, but they manage fire classification, moisture exposure, maintenance, appearance, and documentation differently. See which questions matter before selecting a roof system in Missouri or Illinois.
For most homeowners the choice between a metal roof and cedar shakes depends on priorities and the full roof assembly: cedar gives authentic wood texture but needs drying, debris control, and maintenance; metal provides panel or shingle options but requires verification of fire listing, attachment, and finish for the exact system.
Key takeaways
- A roof fire classification is an assembly-specific, test-based question; wood shakes should not be assumed to have the same classification as metal.
- Cedar needs room to dry and active debris and moss management; metal still depends on correct underlayment, flashing, attachment, and inspections.
- Choose cedar for authentic, evolving wood character; choose a metal profile based on whether a shingle-like or standing-seam appearance fits the home.
- In Missouri and Illinois, make a property-specific decision using written product data, local code and permit requirements, roof measurements, and warranty documents.
What is the main tradeoff between metal and cedar roofs?
Cedar shakes are real wood pieces with a rough, dimensional surface; metal roofing is a broad category that includes panels and shingles. The National Roofing Contractors Association notes that metal shingles may be made to simulate traditional coverings, including wood shakes, while wood shakes retain their own natural look. That makes the appearance decision unusually personal: a homeowner may value authentic wood weathering, while another may prefer a more controlled profile and color[1].
Compare the specific roof’s slope, valleys, chimney and wall intersections, penetrations, eaves, attic conditions, overhanging trees, and local permitting requirements. Its installed options are Stone-Coated Steel Shingles, a premium metal-shingle profile, and Standing Seam Metal Roofing; it does not install cedar shakes.
| Decision factor | Metal roof | Cedar shakes | What to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fire classification | May have a listed Class A assembly depending on product and configuration. | Many products are Class C or unrated; some factory-treated products may be Class A. | Exact test/listing, deck, underlayment, treatment, and local requirement. |
| Moisture approach | Relies on specified panels or shingles, underlayment, attachment, flashing, and transitions. | Relies on correct exposure, interlayment, drainage, drying, and debris control. | Valleys, walls, penetrations, eaves, attic conditions, and gutters. |
| Routine care | Inspect details and drainage; follow product-specific finish and maintenance instructions. | Manage debris, moss, shade, cleaning, and condition changes over time. | Written maintenance guidance, safe access, and inspection intervals. |
| Appearance | Standing seam is linear and architectural; stone-coated steel shingles are dimensional and traditional in character. | Natural split-wood texture that weathers and varies with exposure. | Samples, full roof-plane scale, trim, color, and neighborhood or association rules. |
| Documentation | Product data, instructions, attachment, flashing, fire listing, finish care, and warranties. | Species/grade, treatment if applicable, installation details, care plan, and fire documentation. | A proposal that names every component and written warranty terms. |
| Missouri and Illinois exposure | System details should reflect rain, wind, hail, freeze, and site-specific drainage exposure. | Drying conditions, shade, debris, and moisture retention deserve special attention. | Local code, wind criteria, tree cover, roof geometry, and observed conditions. |
How should I verify fire performance for each roof?
NRCA says many wood shingles and shakes have Class C ratings or no rating, while some factory-treated wood products can achieve Class A. It also says some metal roofing products have Class A ratings. The relevant product literature, treatment, deck, underlayment, and local code requirement determine what applies to a particular home[1].
ASTM E108 evaluates roof coverings for external simulated fire exposure, including flame spread, fire penetration, burning brands, flying brands, and rain exposure. It is a comparison test, not a prediction of every real fire scenario[2]. The IRC likewise treats fire class as a roof-covering requirement and identifies certain metal sheets or shingles on noncombustible decks as Class A assemblies. Confirm the listed assembly rather than transferring a rating from an advertisement or a different deck configuration[3].
How do moisture, drainage, and drying differ by material?
Neither material excuses weak water management. The IRC requires roof assemblies to protect the building when installed to code and approved manufacturer instructions, and it calls for flashing at roof-to-wall intersections, changes in slope or direction, and openings in the roof plane[3]. On either choice, the estimator should locate valleys, skylights, chimneys, sidewalls, low-slope transitions, gutters, and any evidence of deck or attic moisture before specifying details.
Cedar has an additional drying-management burden. The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau says heavy moss can back water up over shingles and that moss retains soil and moisture that can harm wood; accumulated needles, leaves, branches, and dirt affect cedar’s lifespan[4]. Oregon State University Extension explains that repeated wetting and drying can lead to splitting, cupping, and warping, while moss and debris can keep a roof wet longer and encourage decay organisms[5].
What maintenance should I expect for cedar versus metal?
Cedar maintenance is closely tied to the surrounding site. Branch shade can slow drying, and debris can form a water trap. Extension guidance calls for regular removal of leaf litter, needles, and debris, along with attention to gutters and overhanging vegetation[5]. The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau also advises professional cleaning of accumulated debris and cautions against sealing cedar because trapped moisture cannot evaporate normally[4].
A metal roof still merits periodic professional observation of flashings, roof penetrations, trim, gutters, sealants where the approved system uses them, and changes after storms or nearby work. Ask the installer to identify the manufacturer-required maintenance actions, access limitations, finish-care guidance, and who will document an inspection; do not treat any roof covering as exempt from care.
How do cedar and metal compare in appearance options?
Cedar offers grain, split texture, variation, and a surface that naturally changes over time. Oregon State University Extension notes that cedar roofs commonly turn light gray within a year, while sun, rain, wind, and wet-dry cycles continue to weather the exposed wood[5]. That evolution can be desirable, but it also means a cedar roof’s appearance is influenced by slope, shade, moisture, and maintenance rather than remaining visually static.
Metal can take two notably different visual directions. Stone-Coated Steel Shingles can provide a dimensional shingle-oriented look for homeowners who want a more traditional roof form, while Standing Seam Metal Roofing uses long vertical panels and concealed-fastener detailing characteristic of the system. NRCA distinguishes metal panels from metal shingles and recognizes that metal shingles can simulate shake-like traditional coverings[1]. Review installed samples, roof-plane scale, trim, color, and the way each profile resolves valleys and transitions.
What Missouri and Illinois factors affect the choice?
Missouri’s climate ranges from roughly 34 to 50 inches of mean annual precipitation across the state; thunderstorms are most frequent from April through July, and hail occurs in all regions, with May having the most hail days. The University of Missouri also notes freezing temperatures statewide and high-intensity precipitation in all regions[6]. Those conditions support a careful review of drainage, edge details, fasteners, and post-storm inspection plans.
Illinois has its own severe-weather context. The Illinois State Climatologist reports that environments favorable for strong winds, tornadoes, and large hail have increased over recent decades, while also noting uncertainty about the extent of climate change’s contribution to those trends[7]. That does not establish how either roof will perform on one house. Tree cover, roof pitch, local wind design criteria, exposure, deck condition, drainage, and the manufacturer-approved assembly remain property-specific questions.
What documents should I request before deciding?
Request documents that identify the entire assembly, not merely the surface material: exact product and finish, approved installation instructions, fire classification or listing for the proposed configuration, underlayment, attachment method, flashing and valley details, ventilation or attic observations, and deck-repair scope. The IRC addresses metal roof shingles, metal panels, wood shingles, and wood shakes separately, and requires underlayment and application to follow the applicable provisions and approved instructions[3]. Local code adoption and permit review are determined by the authority having jurisdiction.
Use the same checklist for every proposal. It should identify exclusions, change-order process, permit responsibility, cleanup, ventilation assumptions, storm-damage findings, and copies of manufacturer and contractor warranty documents. Bishop's offers financing and states a 50-year warranty; the current written warranty controls every term, condition, exclusion, transfer provision, and remedy.
When it fits
- You want either a shingle-like metal profile or a standing-seam roofline and are prepared to compare approved details rather than surface appearance alone.
- Your decision places a high value on documented fire classification, attachment, flashing, and manufacturer instructions for the proposed metal assembly.
- Your site has recurring debris, shade, or moisture-retention concerns that make a cedar-care plan less attractive.
- You want a proposal with a defined scope for roof transitions, deck observations, warranty documents, and financing options.
When it may not fit
- Authentic wood grain, split texture, and naturally weathered cedar character are non-negotiable design priorities.
- A homeowner is not prepared to assess tree shade, debris accumulation, drying conditions, and periodic cedar-care needs.
- The roof has unresolved deck, drainage, attic-moisture, or flashing conditions that must be diagnosed before choosing any new covering.
- A proposal does not identify the exact roof assembly, code or permit assumptions, product documents, and written warranty terms.
This page is general educational information, not a site inspection, engineering opinion, code determination, fire-risk assessment, insurance advice, estimate, or warranty promise. Product approvals, test listings, code adoption, permits, wind and snow requirements, roof geometry, deck condition, ventilation, drainage, site exposure, and scope must be verified for the individual property by the appropriate professionals and authority having jurisdiction. Current written product and contractor warranty documents control their terms.