Metal Roofing Comparisons
Steel vs. Aluminum Metal Roofing
Steel and aluminum can both serve in a metal roof, but corrosion exposure, thermal movement, profile, and system-specific test evidence—not metal name alone—should drive the decision.
For most inland Missouri and Illinois homes, a properly specified coated-steel system is the practical starting point because steel is rigid, widely available in many profiles, and matches Bishop’s residential offerings. Consider aluminum when exposure is unusually corrosive or a low-weight substrate is required; it requires greater thermal-movement detailing.
Key takeaways
- Coated steel and aluminum solve corrosion differently: steel relies on its specified metallic coating and finish, while aluminum has inherent corrosion resistance but is not exempt from project-specific compatibility and finish concerns.[1][6]
- Aluminum’s greater thermal movement makes panel length, clip design, seams, trim, and installation instructions especially important.[3]
- A roof’s documented assembly—not the metal label—supports claims about design loads, uplift, weatherability, impact, and water performance.[1][2]
- For a Missouri or Illinois home, local code, roof geometry, drainage, deck condition, exposure, and the selected manufacturer system still require property-specific review.[1]
Which factors determine the choice between steel and aluminum?
Steel and aluminum are substrates, not complete roofs. A comparison should begin with the building’s exposure, roof geometry, drainage paths, panel or shingle profile, and the support and attachment below it. Department of Energy’s Building America Solution Center notes that steel and aluminum are common metal-roof materials and that corrosion resistance, attachment, flashing, underlayment, and local requirements are part of the assembly decision.[1]
For an inland residential project in Missouri or Illinois, do not assume that either metal is automatically right statewide. A site near salt storage, persistent runoff, industrial emissions, tree debris, standing water, or incompatible metals needs a more specific material-and-detail review. That is a different question from whether a contractor serves a particular municipality; it is a product and exposure decision for the individual property.[1]
| Decision factor | Coated steel | Aluminum | What to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Corrosion strategy | Relies on specified metallic coating and finish | Has inherent corrosion resistance | Exposure, coating/finish, cut edges, drainage, and compatible accessories |
| Thermal movement | Moves less for a given panel length and temperature change | Moves more; movement detailing is especially important | Panel length, clips, fixed points, seams, trim, and penetrations |
| Rigidity and appearance | Often selected where rigidity is a priority | Lighter material; visual performance depends on thickness, profile, and support | Exact thickness, profile, striations, deck, and expected appearance |
| System evidence | Depends on the named roof product and attachment assembly | Depends on the named roof product and attachment assembly | Current installation guide, evaluation report, uplift/water/impact evidence where applicable |
| Bishop's scope | Stone-Coated Steel Shingles are a stated offering | Do not assume availability from a general comparison | Written proposal naming the substrate, profile, finish, and accessories |
| Energy decision | Finish and rated solar properties drive the assessment | Finish and rated solar properties drive the assessment | Current solar reflectance and emittance for the chosen color/product |
How does corrosion exposure affect substrate selection?
Steel roofing commonly uses a metallic coating beneath the paint finish to protect the steel substrate. Aluminum has inherent corrosion resistance, which can make it a strong candidate for demanding corrosion exposures. The distinction is not a promise that either roof will remain unaffected: finish selection, cut edges, drainage, debris, contact with other metals, and compatible accessories still matter.[1][6]
Ask for the proposed coil or shingle specification, including substrate, metallic coating where applicable, finish, and accessory materials. Building America specifically cautions against mixing metals that are chemically incompatible and calls for corrosion-resistant clips and fasteners as the manufacturer specifies. A compatible flashing and fastener package can matter as much as the roof field.[1]
How much more does aluminum expand versus steel?
All metal roofing changes dimension as temperature changes, while the structure below it may move differently. Petersen Aluminum reports that, over a 100°F swing, a 30-foot aluminum panel could move about 7/16 inch compared with about one-quarter inch for a comparable steel panel. The exact amount depends on metal type, panel length, and temperature change.[3]
That difference does not disqualify aluminum. It means the selected panel length, fixed and floating points, concealed clips, seams, trim, and penetrations must follow that product’s instructions. ASTM E1514 likewise frames a standing-seam steel system around panels, clips, anchorage, and sealers designed for loads and thermal effects without seam separation, permanent buckling, or loss of weather-tightness.[2][3]
How do strength, dent resistance, and roof form differ?
Material comparison should not stop at gauge or thickness because steel and aluminum use different thickness conventions and profiles add stiffness. Steel’s higher rigidity can be useful where visual flatness and dent resistance are priorities, while aluminum’s lower weight may matter on some structures. These are starting points for engineering and product review, not a substitute for checking the proposed assembly.[6]
Stone-coated steel shingles are modular, while standing seam is a panel system with concealed attachment in many designs. The Building America guide distinguishes shingles and panels, describes standing seam as clip-attached, and notes that product reports can identify material, installation requirements, fire classification, wind uplift resistance, and impact rating.[1]
What systems and materials does Bishop's install?
Availability is a system question, not simply a metal question. A profile, seam type, finish, trim package, and tested attachment method may be offered in one substrate but not another, or may have different limits. Confirm the currently available system, color, lead time, substrate, finish, thickness, accessories, and written warranty terms before choosing on a general steel-versus-aluminum assumption.[1][6]
Bishop's installs two residential metal-roof categories: Stone-Coated Steel Shingles and Standing Seam Metal Roofing. The proposal should identify the actual product and complete assembly selected for the home.
What installed-system evidence should I request?
For standing seam, request evidence tied to the exact system rather than relying on broad claims about metal. ASTM E1514 covers design, construction, and weatherability of structural standing-seam steel roof systems, including panels, concealed clips, anchorage, and joint sealers; it calls for consideration of design loads, thermal effects, and static and uplift testing.[2]
A Metal Construction Association assessment of 14 low-slope, unpainted 55% aluminum-zinc-coated steel standing-seam roofs found that ancillary components could corrode sooner than panels and recommended regular inspections and cleaning. It is useful evidence for similar coated-steel conditions, not a service-life prediction or warranty for a Missouri or Illinois residence.[4]
How do finish and energy performance compare?
Steel versus aluminum does not by itself determine roof temperature or household energy use. Department of Energy advises looking at solar reflectance, reflectance retention, and emittance; for painted metal, finish color and the rated product are more relevant than the substrate label. It also notes that climate, insulation, roof type, and HVAC efficiency affect savings.[5]
For a home in Missouri or Illinois, verify local permit and code requirements, design loads, roof slope, deck condition, drainage, ventilation, snow-management needs where relevant, and flashing at walls and penetrations. Building America says metal roofing should be installed to manufacturer instructions and applicable codes and that a roof replacement can be an opportunity to inspect deck and flashing conditions.[1]
When it fits
- You want to compare a proposed coated-steel roof with an aluminum alternative using the property’s actual exposure rather than marketing labels.
- Your roof design uses standing seam panels and you can obtain the specific clip, seam, panel-length, and test documentation.
- You are assessing corrosion exposure, dead-load sensitivity, movement detailing, and finish choices before accepting a proposal.
- You want Bishop's proposed Stone-Coated Steel Shingles or Standing Seam Metal Roofing documented by exact product and assembly.
When it may not fit
- You need a guaranteed outcome for hail, leaks, corrosion, energy bills, or roof service life; no substrate comparison can provide that.
- You are choosing only by a generic gauge number, a color swatch, or a material label without reviewing the installed system.
- The building has unresolved deck damage, drainage, flashing, structural, or code issues that must be evaluated before material selection.
- You require an aluminum product but do not yet have written confirmation that the exact profile and system are available for the proposed scope.
This page is educational, not an engineering opinion, code determination, product-availability commitment, quote, or performance guarantee. Material, finish, panel or shingle profile, deck, drainage, attachment, flashing, local requirements, and exposure must be reviewed for the individual property. Bishop's states a 50-year warranty; the current written warranty controls every term, coverage condition, exclusion, transfer provision, and remedy.