Standing Seam Answers
Must old cedar shakes be removed before installing standing seam roofing?
Not always—overlay can be permitted, but the existing shakes and deck must be assessed for deterioration, fastening support, moisture/ventilation, concealed combustible space, flashing transitions, and the panel manufacturer’s substrate instructions and locally adopted code; if these cannot be verified or corrected, tear-off is the safer path.
What factors decide if shakes must be removed?
- Deck exposure and support
- Cedar shakes can conceal skip or spaced sheathing, damaged boards, or irregular surfaces. A standing-seam system needs a substrate and fastening path that match its approved details; a visual roof inspection cannot establish concealed deck capacity[1][2][3].
- Moisture and decay
- Leaks, trapped moisture, or condensation can weaken wood beneath a new covering. USDA research describes decay above 30% moisture content, with a 20–30% gray area; investigation must be property-specific[4].
- Code and combustible space
- The IRC generally defines replacement as removal to the deck, but allows listed recover paths, including certain metal coverings over wood shakes. Where a concealed combustible space is created, the code calls for approved covering; the locally adopted edition controls[1].
- Ventilation and drainage
- NRCA identifies ventilation and drainage as replacement design priorities. A new panel system should not be treated as a cure for attic moisture, and ridge, intake, eave, or drainage changes need an assembly-level review[2].
- Flashing and manufacturer details
- Walls, chimneys, skylights, valleys, and edges may require new or altered flashings. Manufacturers publish deck-specific instructions rather than one universal overlay recipe, so the selected system’s current manual and accessories must be confirmed[2][3].
| What is found after assessment | Why it affects a standing-seam plan | Appropriate decision path |
|---|---|---|
| Sound, adequately supported substrate; approved recover detail | Panels still need the exact substrate, attachment, underlayment, and fire requirements[1][2] | Consider recover only after written manufacturer and AHJ review |
| Uneven shakes, weak fastener support, or deteriorated deck | NRCA says degraded decks can lose fastener-holding and load capacity[2] | Remove coverings and repair or replace affected deck before metal |
| Moisture or decay indicators | Wood decay is associated with sustained moisture; USDA identifies above 30% moisture content as a decay condition[4] | Investigate the source and concealed assembly; do not cover an unresolved condition |
| Ventilation or flashing transition unresolved | Reroofing can require direct deck access and redesigned edge, wall, penetration, or ventilation details[2] | Resolve the assembly and details before selecting a panel system |
| Local recover, permit, or combustible-space restriction | The IRC permits some metal coverings over shakes only under stated conditions, while local adoption and amendments vary[1][5] | Confirm requirements with the authority having jurisdiction; do not generalize |
How was this conclusion reached?
Overlay claims remain conditional because code adoption, deck construction, moisture, flashing, ventilation, and panel instructions vary. Site review and manufacturer details are required before a decision[1][2][3][4][5].
What should a contractor check and document after cedar shake removal?
Product suitability is not inferred across systems: instructions control.[1][6][7][8][9]
When metal makes sense
- The existing roof is assessed, the substrate is suitable or can be prepared, and the selected manufacturer provides a compliant detail[1][3].
- The owner is prepared to expose the assembly where needed rather than relying on an unseen deck condition[2].
- Ventilation, drainage, and flashing transitions can be documented as part of the complete roof assembly[2].
- The local authority accepts the proposed recover or replacement method under its adopted code[1][5].
When it is not recommended
- The deck or shake assembly is deteriorated, water-soaked, unstable, or unable to provide reliable fastening support[1][2].
- The project depends on concealing unresolved decay, leaks, condensation, unevenness, or drainage problems[2][4].
- The selected manufacturer will not approve the actual substrate, recover method, accessories, or attachment path[3].
- The local authority requires a different sequence, documentation, or removal method, or the homeowner cannot obtain that determination[1][5].
This educational page cannot determine concealed deck soundness, interpret a property’s code or permit requirements, give disposal instructions for every jurisdiction, or recommend installation over wood shakes without site-specific and manufacturer review.