Office: 1700 Scherer Pkwy, St Charles, MO Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 9–2 · Sun closed (314) 730-4080

Metal Roofing Comparisons

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt for Resale Value

A metal roof can improve buyer confidence, but it does not create an automatic resale premium. Compare appraiser evidence, roof condition, appearance, records, buyer timing, and realistic long-term planning against asphalt.

Quick answer

A metal roof is not automatically worth more than asphalt; its resale contribution depends on condition, neighborhood acceptance, comparable sales, appearance, documentation, and the seller’s ownership horizon. New asphalt can remove an immediate objection and may better suit a near-term sale, while detailed records make metal more persuasive in Missouri and Illinois.

Key takeaways

  • An appraisal needs market evidence; installation cost alone does not establish added value.
  • A roof that looks appropriate for the house and neighborhood can matter as much as material category.
  • Keep the contract, scope, permits if applicable, product data, invoices, photos, and written warranty terms.
  • Treat lifetime-cost and resale illustrations as planning tools, not prices, service-life promises, or sale guarantees.

How does a roof affect resale value?

Metal can help a home present as updated, durable, and ready for a buyer, while new asphalt can solve the same urgent concern at a lower initial price. Neither result creates a fixed premium. Fannie Mae requires appraisers to describe improvements and address marketability; improvements should also conform to neighborhood demand, design, and materials.[1]

National remodeling reports can be useful context, but their cost-recovery figures are estimates from industry and real-estate professionals, not an appraisal of a particular Missouri or Illinois home.[2] Ask a local agent and appraiser about closed comparable sales, listing competition, and the buyer profile before treating any national percentage as local value.

Editable 50-year planning illustration
Roof choiceEditable planning assumptionIllustrated total
Asphalt$15,000 × 3$45,000
Metal$35,000 × 1$35,000
Project-specific verificationConfirm the proposed system, current instructions, scope, and site conditions.Review the written documentation.
Project-specific verificationConfirm the proposed system, current instructions, scope, and site conditions.Review the written documentation.
50-year planning illustrationAsphalt: $15,000 × 3 = $45,000. Metal: $35,000 × 1 = $35,000. These are editable 50-year planning assumptions, not a quote, promise, assured service life, or prediction; adjust them with the Roof Lifetime Cost Calculator at /roof-lifetime-cost-calculator/.Use project-specific written estimates.

What roof records help buyers and appraisers?

A resale packet should identify the roof system, installation date, contractor, scope, payment record, product information, repair history, photographs, permit or inspection records when applicable, and the complete written warranty. That file helps a buyer, inspector, insurer, agent, or appraiser distinguish a recent roof from an undocumented assertion.

Do not describe a roof as hail-proof, maintenance-free, leak-proof, or guaranteed to raise value. Keep storm-event photos, claim correspondence, repair invoices, and receipts instead. Missouri’s insurance department advises prompt insurer contact after damage, temporary protection against further damage, retained receipts, and no permanent repair before inspection.[5]

Do Missouri and Illinois storms change resale considerations?

Local permit rules, code adoption, HOA requirements, comparable sales, roof geometry, and insurance terms remain property-specific. Louis archive documents repeated Missouri and Illinois events involving large hail, damaging winds, tornadoes, and flooding.[3]

That history makes accurate, restrained documentation more useful than a sweeping performance claim. In Illinois, a residential seller must deliver the statutory disclosure report before contract signing and disclose known material defects; the statute also says the report is not a substitute for inspections or warranties.[4] Missouri and Illinois transaction advice should still come from the seller’s real-estate and legal professionals.

How does appearance influence buyer reaction?

Stone-Coated Steel Shingles offer a dimensional, shingle-scale metal appearance that may suit homes where a conventional shingle look matters. Standing Seam Metal Roofing uses long, defined panel lines and a more contemporary or architectural expression. Review full-size samples, color, trim, penetrations, valleys, and the roof from the street—not only a small swatch.

The best resale appearance is not universal. A crisp standing seam roof can be a strong architectural match on one home, while a shingle-like profile may feel more consistent on another. Fannie Mae notes that market resistance from incompatible design, quality, size, condition, or materials must be addressed in valuation and marketability analysis.[1]

Why do system details matter for metal roofs?

Standing seam is a system, not merely a visual style. Panel type, roof slope, substrate, clips, expansion, flashings, penetrations, ventilation, and manufacturer instructions affect the completed assembly. McElroy’s installation manual differentiates architectural and structural approaches and emphasizes installation guidance; use the exact selected system documents for the project.[6]

For stone-coated steel, save the exact product profile, accessory list, installer scope, and warranty document. Manufacturer homeowner materials direct owners to warranty and care information, but they do not replace the project’s written terms or a condition inspection.[7] At resale, a complete, matched system record is more credible than a generic claim about ‘metal.’

Should I use long-term lifetime projections for resale?

They are not a quote, promise, assured service life, forecast, appraisal adjustment, or prediction of what a buyer will pay. Actual costs and timing depend on roof area, complexity, tear-off, deck condition, code, labor, storm events, maintenance, and the chosen system.

If you may sell soon, compare the immediate price, curb appeal, buyer objections removed, and evidence available at listing; do not assume a 50-year horizon will become a sale-price premium.

Which roof should I choose and how should I document it?

Asphalt can be rational when initial budget, a near-term sale, or neighborhood convention leads the decision. Metal can be rational when the homeowner wants a premium architectural system and expects to benefit from it longer. Neither choice excuses a poor deck, incomplete flashing work, weak ventilation analysis, or missing records.

Bishop's is a residential metal-only specialist serving Missouri and Illinois, offering Stone-Coated Steel Shingles, Standing Seam Metal Roofing, and financing. Bishop's states a 50-year warranty, but the current written warranty controls every term, limitation, transfer condition, and remedy. Review the proposal and warranty before relying on either in a listing or negotiation.

When it fits

  • You expect to own the home long enough for a premium metal system’s non-price benefits to matter to you.
  • The selected profile, color, and trim complement the home and are likely to fit the surrounding buyer market.
  • You will preserve a complete project and warranty file for future buyers, inspectors, and appraisers.
  • Your budget supports the installed system and its project-specific details without depending on a promised resale premium.

When it may not fit

  • You need the lowest feasible immediate roof cost and a new asphalt system meets the property’s needs.
  • You plan to sell soon and have no local comparable evidence that supports a premium beyond a sound, market-ready roof.
  • The desired metal profile conflicts with HOA rules, local requirements, the home’s architecture, or likely buyer expectations.
  • You are choosing metal primarily because someone promised an exact recovery rate, insurance outcome, or storm-proof result.

Run your own numbers in the roof lifetime cost calculator.

This page is educational, not an appraisal, inspection, insurance, legal, tax, engineering, code, or real-estate advice. Resale value, permits, condition, insurance, financing, warranty coverage, and buyer response are property- and transaction-specific. Obtain project-specific written scope and warranty documents, verify local requirements, and consult qualified local professionals.

FAQ

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt for Resale Value: common questions

Does a metal roof always increase home value more than asphalt?

No. A metal roof can improve buyer confidence and curb appeal, but value is determined from the property, market reaction, condition, and comparable evidence. Fannie Mae’s guidance requires analysis of marketability and compatible improvements rather than a mechanical dollar-for-dollar adjustment from installation cost.[1]

Will an appraiser give me the full cost of a metal roof back?

Not automatically. An appraiser is not required to convert your invoice into value. Cost is useful documentation, but comparable sales and market reaction remain important. Give the appraiser the contract, scope, date, product data, warranty, permits if applicable, and clear photos, then let the appraisal process determine support.[1]

Is new asphalt a poor choice if I expect to sell soon?

No. New asphalt may be the sensible choice when it resolves a visible condition issue, matches the neighborhood, and fits the sale timeline and budget. A metal roof’s higher initial investment does not assure a matching short-term premium. Discuss local buyer expectations with a qualified real-estate professional.

What roof records should I give a future buyer?

Provide the signed contract, itemized scope, invoices, payment record, manufacturer product and care documents, the complete current written warranty, transfer instructions, permits or inspections if applicable, photographs, and any later repair records. These records support transparency but do not replace a buyer’s inspection or statutory disclosure duties.[4]

Do Missouri and Illinois storms make a metal roof a guaranteed resale advantage?

No. National Weather Service records show that parts of Missouri and Illinois experience severe weather, including large hail and damaging winds, which may make roof condition and records important to buyers. They do not predict a particular roof’s performance, insurance result, appraisal adjustment, or resale price.[3]

How should I interpret Bishop's 50-year warranty statement when selling?

Present the complete current written warranty, not a shortened marketing phrase. Confirm the named product, coverage, exclusions, transfer process, notice requirements, and any maintenance or installation conditions. Bishop's states a 50-year warranty, but only the current written warranty controls its terms; it is not a promise of service life or resale value.

References

Sources

  1. B4-1.3-05, Improvements Section of the Appraisal Report — Fannie Mae
  2. Remodeling Impact — National Association of REALTORS®
  3. Significant Weather Event Reviews — NOAA National Weather Service St. Louis, Missouri
  4. Residential Real Property Disclosure Act — Illinois General Assembly
  5. Tips for Filing Claims, Preventing Further Damage — Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance
  6. Metal Roofing Installation Manual — McElroy Metal
  7. DECRA Homeowners Manual — DECRA Metal Roofing

Built to last. Backed by Bishop's.

Make your next roof your last.

Two metal systems, one installation standard. In a consultation we inspect the roof, explain which system fits the house, and put the scope, warranty and financing options in writing.

Schedule consultation Call now